Overview of The Best 2020 Axial-Flow Fan Data and Inclusion in Similarity Charts for the Search of the Best Design

Abstract

This article deals with the aerodynamic performance of ducted axial-flow fans available in the 2020 market and aims to create a general picture of the best designs and design trends, as a tool for fan designers. To this end, this article first presents the general formulation of the similarity approach to the fan performance analysis, including the effects of rotational speed (which affects the validity of the Reynolds similarity) and turbomachine size (which can hinder the perfect geometrical similarity of some shape details). The second part reports a statistical survey of the axial-flow fan performance based on data from catalogues of major manufacturers and compares the resulting Cordier lines with optimum fan designs from empirical or computational fluid-dynamics (CFD)-based models available in the literature. In addition to the global performance at maximum aeraulic and total-to-static efficiencies, this survey uses the form of dimensionless Balje–Cordier charts to identify the trends and values of other design parameters, such as hub-to-tip ratio, blade count, and blade positioning angle. As a result, a summary of the aerodynamic performance of year 2020 best designs, the improvements achieved during the last 40 years, and the present design trends in contrarotating, vane-axial, and tube-axial fan types are made available to fan designers.