Seismic Response and Design of Steel Multitiered Concentrically Braced Frames Not Specifically Detailed for Seismic Resistance

Abstract

Steel multitiered concentrically braced frames (MT-CBFs) not specifically detailed for seismic resistance with a response modification factor of R=3 are permitted in moderate seismic regions. Past research studies, however, have raised concerns regarding the seismic performance of MT-CBFs and CBFs designed using R=3 provisions, namely the stability of columns in MT-CBFs and connection limit states in R=3 CBFs. This paper examines the seismic response of R=3 MT-CBFs and proposes a design method to improve their seismic performance. A set of 16 prototype R=3 MT-CBFs, ranging from 8 to 20 m tall with two to five tiers and located in a moderate seismic area, was selected and designed in accordance with 2016 US design guidelines. Nonlinear response-history analyses were then performed to examine the seismic response of these frames using fiber-based numerical models. R=3 MT-CBFs designed to 2016 design guidelines are shown to experience premature fracture in brace-to-beam/column connections in a single tier, which imposes high in-plane bending demands on columns and in some cases, leads to column instability or a tier-sway mechanism. New seismic design recommendations, including requirements for intermediate struts, columns, and tier drift, are proposed. The design method aims to prevent column instability or a tier-sway mechanism and protect brace connections from excessive deformation.