Screening Level Risk Assessment of Heavy Metal Contamination in Cleveland Area Commons

Abstract

Commons are public lands that are often used for recreational activities and are generally assumed to be free of soil contamination. However, in old industrial cities, urban commons may have accumulated heavy metal burdens from airborne contamination. This paper examines the heavy metal burdens and risk analysis results for 50 commons in the greater Cleveland, Ohio area. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Method 3050B and 1N HCl soil extraction results are presented for Cd, Cr, Cu, Ni, Pb, and Zn mass burdens, and are interpreted relative to Ohio residential soil guidance and “typical” values from the remediation guidance of 30 states. Results demonstrate that most of these soils have heavy metal burdens that are well above naturally occurring levels, and several (at least 8 of the 50 sites tested) have heavy metal burdens that exceed Ohio’s residential soil contamination guidance. Lead and cadmium were found to be the most significant contributors to site hazard index values.