Long-Term Field Response of Skewed Steel I-Girder Bridge Superstructures under Thermal Variation

Abstract

To investigate the performance of in-service skewed bridges, two continuous two-span steel I-girder bridges, one skewed 45° with integral abutments and the other skewed 41° with stub abutments, were instrumented during construction for long-term field monitoring. The bridges are located near each other and experience similar traffic volume and thermal variation, from roughly −18°C to 38°C (0°F to 100°F). Critical girders and cross-frames were instrumented with strain gauges and/or tiltmeters, and temperature was recorded at each sensor. Superstructure response over more than 2 years of data collection was recorded and studied, including for the in-service first-stage half bridges (temporarily for 6 months) and the full bridges. Girder cross-sections and cross-frames were within the elastic range during field monitoring, so stress directly relates to measured strain. The bridge superstructures experienced cyclic stress variation under thermal loading—there was clear linear correlation between bridge response and seasonal temperature variation, especially for decomposed girder axial stress and strong-axis bending stress. Deviation from the correlation was observed due to changes in abutment restraint during seasonal temperature variation and thermal gradient under daily temperature changes. Exterior girders were frequently unevenly heated by direct sunlight, which induced a diverging daily stress–temperature relationship compared to long-term observations. Thermal response of exterior girders is more complex than interior girders regarding both strong-axis and lateral bending, which is often not incorporated in standard bridge design procedures. Several girder bottom flanges and cross-frame members exhibited atypical increasing stress that started during the first cold-weather period; some of the stress development continued over time, regardless of long-term thermal cycles.