| description abstract | Commercial buildings generally have large thermal inertia and thus can provide services to power grids (e.g., demand response (DR)) by modulating their heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) systems. Shifting consumption on timescales of minutes to an hour can be accomplished through temperature setpoint adjustments that affect HVAC fan consumption. Estimating the counterfactual baseline power consumption of HVAC fans is challenging but is critical for assessing the capacity and participation of DR from HVAC fans in grid-interactive efficient buildings (GEBs). DR baseline methods have been developed for whole-building power profiles. This study evaluates those methods on total HVAC fan power profiles, which have different characteristics than whole-building power profiles. Specifically, we assess averaging methods (e.g., Y-day average, HighXofY, and MidXofY, with and without additive adjustments), which are the most commonly used in practice, and a least squares-based linear interpolation method recently developed for baselining HVAC fan power. We use empirical submetering data from HVAC fans in three University of Michigan buildings in our assessment. We find that the linear interpolation method has a low bias and by far the highest accuracy, indicating that it is potentially the most effective existing baseline method for quantifying the effects of short-term load shifting of HVAC fans. Overall, our results provide new insights on the applicability of existing DR baseline methods to baselining fan power and enable the more widespread contribution of GEBs to DR and other grid services. | |
