Application of Boyd’s Periodization and Relaxation Method in a Spectral Atmospheric Limited-Area Model. Part II: Accuracy Analysis and Detailed Study of the Operational Impact

Abstract

pectral limited-area models face a particular challenge at their lateral boundaries: the fields need to be made periodic. Boyd proposed a windowing-based method to improve the periodization and relaxation. In a companion paper, the implementation of this windowing method in the operational semi-implicit semi-Lagrangian spectral HARMONIE system was described and some first reproducibility tests, comparing this method to the old existing one, were presented.The present paper provides an in-depth study of the impact of this method for different configurations of the implementation. This is carried out in three steps in well-controlled experimental setups of increasing complexity. First, different aspects of Boyd?s method are analyzed in an idealized perfect-model test using a representative 1D shallow-water model. Second, the implementation is tested in an adiabatic 3D numerical weather prediction (NWP) model with perfect-model experiments. Finally, the impact of using Boyd?s method in a more operational-like NWP context is investigated as well. The presented tests show that, while the implementation of Boyd?s method is neutral in terms of scores, it is superior to the existing spline method in the case of strong dynamical forcings at the lateral boundaries.