YaBeSH Engineering and Technology Library

    • Journals
    • PaperQuest
    • YSE Standards
    • YaBeSH
    • Login
    View Item 
    •   YE&T Library
    • AMS
    • Journal of Applied Meteorology
    • View Item
    •   YE&T Library
    • AMS
    • Journal of Applied Meteorology
    • View Item
    • All Fields
    • Source Title
    • Year
    • Publisher
    • Title
    • Subject
    • Author
    • DOI
    • ISBN
    Advanced Search
    JavaScript is disabled for your browser. Some features of this site may not work without it.

    Archive

    Analysis of the Israeli Cloud Seeding Experiment by means of Concomitant Meteorological Variables

    Source: Journal of Applied Meteorology:;1971:;volume( 010 ):;issue: 006::page 1185
    Author:
    Wurtele, Zivia S.
    DOI: 10.1175/1520-0450(1971)010<1185:AOTICS>2.0.CO;2
    Publisher: American Meteorological Society
    Abstract: This paper summarizes results of a statistical analysis of the Israeli cloud-seeding experiment (1961?67) based upon precipitation data for the period of the experiment and upon 30 concomitant meteorological variables, both surface and upper air. The experiment had a crossover design in which days are allocated at random to seeding in one of two (North or Center) targets, separated by a Buffer region. Two statistical tests are used, one based upon normal theory and the other a Wilcoxon two-sample (nonparametric) test. On the basis of these tests it is reasonable to accept the hypothesis that cloud seeding affected precipitation; results are significant for two-sided tests at the 2.5% level in the case of the normal test and at the 10% level in the case of the Wilcoxon test. However, when these same test procedures were applied to the Buffer region instead of the Center target, even more significant results were obtained. Analysis of plume directions at the times of seeding do not indicate that this contamination was due to physical transport of seeding material. This result with regard to the Buffer strongly suggests the possibility of contamination of one target by seeding of the other. The meteorological assumptions underlying a crossover experiment are that contamination effects are negligible in comparison to the effects of seeding in the target area. When such assumptions are not valid, interpretation of the results of a crossover experiment may be grossly misleading; in fact, they may be in the wrong direction. On the assumption that this is not the case for the Israeli experiment, i.e., that crossover effects are negligible, an attempt is made to determine the differential effects of seeding under different meteorological conditions. It is estimated that in an operational year there would be about 35 days of actual seeding with increases of 1.9 mm day?1 in the North and 2.2 mm in the Center. No evidence of large negative effects in target areas was found, but in about 10?20% of the days there may have been moderate or slight negative effects. Meteorological conditions on such days are associated with warm surface air moving from the south. Positive effects are associated with meteorological conditions that are conducive to greater than average rainfall. Tables with details about partitionings of the data by means of meteorological variables are provided.
    • Download: (707.7Kb)
    • Show Full MetaData Hide Full MetaData
    • Item Order
    • Go To Publisher
    • Statistics

      Analysis of the Israeli Cloud Seeding Experiment by means of Concomitant Meteorological Variables

    URI
    https://yetl.yabesh.ir/yetl1/handle/yetl/4225711
    Collections
    • Journal of Applied Meteorology

    Show full item record

    contributor authorWurtele, Zivia S.
    date accessioned2017-06-09T17:17:42Z
    date available2017-06-09T17:17:42Z
    date copyright1971/12/01
    date issued1971
    identifier issn0021-8952
    identifier otherams-8258.pdf
    identifier urihttp://onlinelibrary.yabesh.ir/handle/yetl/4225711
    description abstractThis paper summarizes results of a statistical analysis of the Israeli cloud-seeding experiment (1961?67) based upon precipitation data for the period of the experiment and upon 30 concomitant meteorological variables, both surface and upper air. The experiment had a crossover design in which days are allocated at random to seeding in one of two (North or Center) targets, separated by a Buffer region. Two statistical tests are used, one based upon normal theory and the other a Wilcoxon two-sample (nonparametric) test. On the basis of these tests it is reasonable to accept the hypothesis that cloud seeding affected precipitation; results are significant for two-sided tests at the 2.5% level in the case of the normal test and at the 10% level in the case of the Wilcoxon test. However, when these same test procedures were applied to the Buffer region instead of the Center target, even more significant results were obtained. Analysis of plume directions at the times of seeding do not indicate that this contamination was due to physical transport of seeding material. This result with regard to the Buffer strongly suggests the possibility of contamination of one target by seeding of the other. The meteorological assumptions underlying a crossover experiment are that contamination effects are negligible in comparison to the effects of seeding in the target area. When such assumptions are not valid, interpretation of the results of a crossover experiment may be grossly misleading; in fact, they may be in the wrong direction. On the assumption that this is not the case for the Israeli experiment, i.e., that crossover effects are negligible, an attempt is made to determine the differential effects of seeding under different meteorological conditions. It is estimated that in an operational year there would be about 35 days of actual seeding with increases of 1.9 mm day?1 in the North and 2.2 mm in the Center. No evidence of large negative effects in target areas was found, but in about 10?20% of the days there may have been moderate or slight negative effects. Meteorological conditions on such days are associated with warm surface air moving from the south. Positive effects are associated with meteorological conditions that are conducive to greater than average rainfall. Tables with details about partitionings of the data by means of meteorological variables are provided.
    publisherAmerican Meteorological Society
    titleAnalysis of the Israeli Cloud Seeding Experiment by means of Concomitant Meteorological Variables
    typeJournal Paper
    journal volume10
    journal issue6
    journal titleJournal of Applied Meteorology
    identifier doi10.1175/1520-0450(1971)010<1185:AOTICS>2.0.CO;2
    journal fristpage1185
    journal lastpage1192
    treeJournal of Applied Meteorology:;1971:;volume( 010 ):;issue: 006
    contenttypeFulltext
    DSpace software copyright © 2002-2015  DuraSpace
    نرم افزار کتابخانه دیجیتال "دی اسپیس" فارسی شده توسط یابش برای کتابخانه های ایرانی | تماس با یابش
    yabeshDSpacePersian
     
    DSpace software copyright © 2002-2015  DuraSpace
    نرم افزار کتابخانه دیجیتال "دی اسپیس" فارسی شده توسط یابش برای کتابخانه های ایرانی | تماس با یابش
    yabeshDSpacePersian