YaBeSH Engineering and Technology Library

    • Journals
    • PaperQuest
    • YSE Standards
    • YaBeSH
    • Login
    View Item 
    •   YE&T Library
    • AMS
    • Weather and Forecasting
    • View Item
    •   YE&T Library
    • AMS
    • Weather and Forecasting
    • View Item
    • All Fields
    • Source Title
    • Year
    • Publisher
    • Title
    • Subject
    • Author
    • DOI
    • ISBN
    Advanced Search
    JavaScript is disabled for your browser. Some features of this site may not work without it.

    Archive

    Neighborhood-Based Verification of Precipitation Forecasts from Convection-Allowing NCAR WRF Model Simulations and the Operational NAM

    Source: Weather and Forecasting:;2010:;volume( 025 ):;issue: 005::page 1495
    Author:
    Clark, Adam J.
    ,
    Gallus, William A.
    ,
    Weisman, Morris L.
    DOI: 10.1175/2010WAF2222404.1
    Publisher: American Meteorological Society
    Abstract: Since 2003 the National Center for Atmospheric Research (NCAR) has been running various experimental convection-allowing configurations of the Weather Research and Forecasting Model (WRF) for domains covering a large portion of the central United States during the warm season (April?July). In this study, the skill of 3-hourly accumulated precipitation forecasts from a large sample of these convection-allowing simulations conducted during 2004?05 and 2007?08 is compared to that from operational North American Mesoscale (NAM) model forecasts using a neighborhood-based equitable threat score (ETS). Separate analyses were conducted for simulations run before and after the implementation in 2007 of positive-definite (PD) moisture transport for the NCAR-WRF simulations. The neighborhood-based ETS (denoted ?ETS?r) relaxes the criteria for ?hits? (i.e., correct forecasts) by considering grid points within a specified radius r. It is shown that ?ETS?r is more useful than the traditional ETS because ?ETS?r can be used to diagnose differences in precipitation forecast skill between different models as a function of spatial scale, whereas the traditional ETS only considers the spatial scale of the verification grid. It was found that differences in ?ETS?r between NCAR-WRF and NAM generally increased with increasing r, with NCAR-WRF having higher scores. Examining time series of ?ETS?r for r = 100 and r = 0 km (which simply reduces to the ?traditional? ETS), statistically significant differences between NCAR-WRF and NAM were found at many forecast lead times for ?ETS?100 but only a few times for ?ETS?0. Larger and more statistically significant differences occurred with the 2007?08 cases relative to the 2004?05 cases. Because of differences in model configurations and dominant large-scale weather regimes, a more controlled experiment would have been needed to diagnose the reason for the larger differences that occurred with the 2007?08 cases. Finally, a compositing technique was used to diagnose the differences in the spatial distribution of the forecasts. This technique implied westward displacement errors for NAM model forecasts in both sets of cases and in NCAR-WRF model forecasts for the 2007?08 cases. Generally, the results are encouraging because they imply that advantages in convection-allowing relative to convection-parameterizing simulations noted in recent studies are reflected in an objective neighborhood-based metric.
    • Download: (2.888Mb)
    • Show Full MetaData Hide Full MetaData
    • Item Order
    • Go To Publisher
    • Statistics

      Neighborhood-Based Verification of Precipitation Forecasts from Convection-Allowing NCAR WRF Model Simulations and the Operational NAM

    URI
    https://yetl.yabesh.ir/yetl1/handle/yetl/4213394
    Collections
    • Weather and Forecasting

    Show full item record

    contributor authorClark, Adam J.
    contributor authorGallus, William A.
    contributor authorWeisman, Morris L.
    date accessioned2017-06-09T16:38:46Z
    date available2017-06-09T16:38:46Z
    date copyright2010/10/01
    date issued2010
    identifier issn0882-8156
    identifier otherams-71496.pdf
    identifier urihttp://onlinelibrary.yabesh.ir/handle/yetl/4213394
    description abstractSince 2003 the National Center for Atmospheric Research (NCAR) has been running various experimental convection-allowing configurations of the Weather Research and Forecasting Model (WRF) for domains covering a large portion of the central United States during the warm season (April?July). In this study, the skill of 3-hourly accumulated precipitation forecasts from a large sample of these convection-allowing simulations conducted during 2004?05 and 2007?08 is compared to that from operational North American Mesoscale (NAM) model forecasts using a neighborhood-based equitable threat score (ETS). Separate analyses were conducted for simulations run before and after the implementation in 2007 of positive-definite (PD) moisture transport for the NCAR-WRF simulations. The neighborhood-based ETS (denoted ?ETS?r) relaxes the criteria for ?hits? (i.e., correct forecasts) by considering grid points within a specified radius r. It is shown that ?ETS?r is more useful than the traditional ETS because ?ETS?r can be used to diagnose differences in precipitation forecast skill between different models as a function of spatial scale, whereas the traditional ETS only considers the spatial scale of the verification grid. It was found that differences in ?ETS?r between NCAR-WRF and NAM generally increased with increasing r, with NCAR-WRF having higher scores. Examining time series of ?ETS?r for r = 100 and r = 0 km (which simply reduces to the ?traditional? ETS), statistically significant differences between NCAR-WRF and NAM were found at many forecast lead times for ?ETS?100 but only a few times for ?ETS?0. Larger and more statistically significant differences occurred with the 2007?08 cases relative to the 2004?05 cases. Because of differences in model configurations and dominant large-scale weather regimes, a more controlled experiment would have been needed to diagnose the reason for the larger differences that occurred with the 2007?08 cases. Finally, a compositing technique was used to diagnose the differences in the spatial distribution of the forecasts. This technique implied westward displacement errors for NAM model forecasts in both sets of cases and in NCAR-WRF model forecasts for the 2007?08 cases. Generally, the results are encouraging because they imply that advantages in convection-allowing relative to convection-parameterizing simulations noted in recent studies are reflected in an objective neighborhood-based metric.
    publisherAmerican Meteorological Society
    titleNeighborhood-Based Verification of Precipitation Forecasts from Convection-Allowing NCAR WRF Model Simulations and the Operational NAM
    typeJournal Paper
    journal volume25
    journal issue5
    journal titleWeather and Forecasting
    identifier doi10.1175/2010WAF2222404.1
    journal fristpage1495
    journal lastpage1509
    treeWeather and Forecasting:;2010:;volume( 025 ):;issue: 005
    contenttypeFulltext
    DSpace software copyright © 2002-2015  DuraSpace
    نرم افزار کتابخانه دیجیتال "دی اسپیس" فارسی شده توسط یابش برای کتابخانه های ایرانی | تماس با یابش
    yabeshDSpacePersian
     
    DSpace software copyright © 2002-2015  DuraSpace
    نرم افزار کتابخانه دیجیتال "دی اسپیس" فارسی شده توسط یابش برای کتابخانه های ایرانی | تماس با یابش
    yabeshDSpacePersian