An Approach to Quantify Anisotropic Multiaxial Failure of the Annulus Fibrosus

Abstract

Tears in the annulus fibrosus (AF) of the intervertebral disk (IVD) occur due to multiaxial loading on the spine. However, most existing AF failure studies measure uniaxial stress, not the multiaxial stress at failure. Delamination theory, which requires advanced structural knowledge and knowledge about the interactions between the AF fibers and matrix, has historically been used to understand and predict AF failure. Alternatively, a simple method, the Tsai-Hill yield criteria, could describe multiaxial failure of the AF. This yield criteria uses the known tissue fiber orientation and an equation to establish the multiaxial failure stresses that cause failure. This paper presents a method to test the multiaxial failure stress of the AF experimentally and evaluate the potential for the Tsai-Hill model to predict these failure stresses. Porcine AF was cut into a dogbone shape at three distinct angles relative to the primary lamella direction (parallel, transverse, and oblique). Then, each dogbone was pulled to complete rupture. The Cauchy stress in the material's fiber coordinates was calculated. These multiaxial stress parameters were used to optimize the coefficients of the Tsai-Hill yield. The coefficients obtained for the Tsai-Hill model vary by an order of magnitude between the fiber and transverse directions, and these coefficients provide a good description of the AF multiaxial failure stress. These results establish both an experimental approach and the use of the Tsai-Hill model to explain the anisotropic failure behavior of the tissue.